Carrie Underwood’s New Video– Love it or Hate it?

Posted on Feb 12 2008 - 12:43pm by Angela | 20 comments

Carrie Underwood may have been honored with the Grammy Award for country female vocal but that doesn't mean that the 24-year-old isn't feeling the pressures of the music industry.

Underwood's latest video for All-American Girl has been receiving some poor reviews - a new type of publicity for Carrie, who has done everything right since she was crowned American Idol winner a few years ago.

Carrie Underwood: Photo Credit: Apega/ WENNThe new video features Ms. Underwood portraying several types of all-American women. From a firefighter, nurse and mom to a football player, chef and stewardess, Carrie is the epitome of All-American girl in her new video.

So what's the problem?

Many of Underwood's biggest fans are dubbing the video as tacky and egotistical.

Carrie is known for producing meaningful videos with great storylines and this new video seems to be a huge disappointment for fans.

It seems as though her tour-buddy Keith Urban seems to be rubbing off on her. After all, all of his videos revolve around him (and only him) and we're disappointed to see Carrie following in his footsteps.

All-American Girl had the potential to be a great video with a great storyline and, for the first time in her career, Carrie failed to deliver.

Were you disappointed with Carrie's new video?

For those of you who haven't seen it, the video can be found here, at youtube.com.

$3.98 - $13.97

Some Hearts by Carrie Underwood
Arista Records (USA) ( November 15, 2005 ), Genre: Rock & PopRead full description ...

Product Rating: Read 25 Epinions reviews

$5.14 - $7.18

Karaoke - Carrie Underwood by Karaoke
BCI Eclipse Records ( September 12, 2006 ), Genre: Rock & PopRead full description ...

$10 - $11

Country Piano Tribute To Carrie Underwood
Copycats Entertainment ( March 13, 2007 ), Genre: Rock & PopRead full description ...

$7 - $17

Do You Remember: Pickin' on Carrie Underwood - The Bluegrass Tribute by Pickin' On
CMH Records ( January 24, 2006 ), Genre: CountryRead full description ...

$10 - $11

Unplugged Tribute to Carrie Underwood
Tribute Sounds ( March 13, 2007 ), Genre: Rock & PopRead full description ...

Bookmark/Search this post with:

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.egossip.com/trackback/933

<< previous | next >>

Comments

Anonymous (not verified)

I was dissappointed with it for sure. It was corny and not very professional - at least not considering what we're used to with her. I still love her though!

Anonymous (not verified)

Are you kidding? I love this video of carrie getting dressed up in different settings. I think it is one of her best yet.

Anonymous (not verified)

I have not heard that Carrie's fans were disappointed with her new video. I think it's good and your comments on Keith Urban were uncalled for. I'm a fan of his and that's the way we want his videos....ALL ABOUT HIM!

Anonymous (not verified)

Are you kidding me? I love this video! It shows the many roles a woman has to take!

NavStar (not verified)

I think it's being blown out of proportion! The video was great! Carrie is only 24 - come on people, let her have some fun! The world isn't all about serious stuff. Sometimes a message needs to be sent out in a playful manner. 'All American Girl' gives out a message but it also makes it a little fun. She plays a President in the video, while portraying many many other professions and positions that females take on. Everyone is entitled to their opinion - but I really don't think it's a big deal. We need to let Carrie have some fun and we need to just recognize that the music, the voice and the lyrics are still GREAT! and Carrie still Rocks!

Anonymous (not verified)

where are u getting ur info from?? the ones who were bashing the video are haters. Perez hilton said it was crappy so all the haters replied that it was just to say something. All of Carrie's biggest fans LOVE the video! I know this for a fact because i am a member of her official fanclub and its been getitng amazing reviews. There are always good and bad reviews.. u are just juding based on some bad ones you saw.

Wow! (not verified)

A playful Carrie is wonderful to see. It's nice seeing her just give us a light hearted moment. The video isn't "all about her," it is a fun video showing the "All American Girl" can be anything she wants to be. Carrie's fans (of all ages) love it.

Anonymous (not verified)

I didn't like it. I like all of her other ones way more. i will always be a carrie fan but we're allowed to not like some of her stuff.

Anonymous (not verified)

I LOVE the video.. i dont know what you are talking about but Carrie Underwood is def. NOT a failure!!!! this is crazy i mean cmon she is 24...i love the video..esp. the part with the before he cheats car in the backround!! WAYY TO GO CARRIE!!! I LOVE IT GOD BLESS YOU <3

Anonymous (not verified)

The video is great - love the lightheartedness for a change!!! These videos don't have to all be serious and love seeing her happy for a change!! Have heard nothing but great comments from my friends about it!!

Anonymous (not verified)

it's something different from Carrie, that's all. i thought it was fun and cute. the most important thing is that it's a great song!

Anonymous (not verified)

I loved the video! It was great to see a playful side of Carrie!

Anonymous (not verified)

I really like the video! It shows a side of Carrie that we haven't seen in her other videos!

Michael (not verified)

You've got to be kidding me. I am a huge Carrie fan, and this is by far Carrie's best video to date! It's great!

Anonymous (not verified)

i thought that the video for All American Gril was great. i thought that it was nice and sweet, nothing too elaborate, it's simple and it does show Carrie's personality, which i think we havent seen in her videos, it's refreshing.

zed (not verified)

Actually, first time I saw the video I laughed like crazy! I remember that video totally made my day. It had some hidden stuff that you just can't help but laughed at. I thought this video was great. Sure it's not like her other videos, but it's actually nice to see her having fun with this one...

Anonymous (not verified)

I agree... the first time I saw it I had the best laugh I'd had in a couple of years. It is G R E A T !!! WTG Carrie

Barry P. Simon (not verified)

The video is pure fun- why not Does everything have to be serious??

Anonymous (not verified)

HOGWASH!!

Mandy (not verified)

I absolutely LOVE this video. It's the best music video I have seen in a long time!!! Not sure what kind of person would think that she is being self-centered. It just shows that she is not only an amazing singer, but potentially a great actress!